Dancing with the Trend

Whipsaws

 | 

We think it is a good time to revisit a topic that is always top of mind for tactical money managers and investors in rules-based strategies like trend following; and that is whipsaws.

Whipsaw trades are the one issue that will constantly concern investors using trend following strategies. Whipsaw trades can cause losses or cause you to miss out on gains, and aside from those monetary impacts, they are difficult to tolerate emotionally. If you are going to do anything different than being a buy & hold investor, you are always going to compare to "what could have been" if you were using a buy & hold strategy.

A whipsaw is basically a trade or change in your investment position that the market does not cooperate with. There are two ways to get whipsawed when trend following. One is to move from being invested to being defensive (i.e., selling) and then the market moves higher and forces you to buy back in at a higher price.

This type of whipsaw does not necessarily cause losses in your account but does cause you to miss out on gains. This trade makes investors think that if they stayed invested and not sold when they did, their account value would have increased; "Everyone else is getting rich and I'm not!"

The second type of whipsaw is when you are defensive and move to being invested (i.e., buying) and the market moves down after you enter, forcing you to sell at a lower price.

This type of whipsaw does cause losses in the account and makes you think that if you weren't so anxious to buy, you could have bought in later at a lower price; "I'm buying high and selling low, this strategy is not working!"

Whipsaws are an inevitable consequence of eschewing the buy and hold approach that will eventually cause you to become a victim of a bear market. Whipsaws are the "cost of doing business" if you want to avoid the devastation that comes during bear markets. We know this fact to be true, watching the market plummet from the sidelines is not a bad thing, emotionally or financially. We never know if a few down days are going to turn into a correction, or if a correction is going to turn into a bear market. No one can reliably predict such things (even though countless people try), but at least we are always prepared for the worst outcome. That is why we accept whipsaw trades in our trend following approach – for the benefit of the downside protection our selling rules provide. It allows us to try to participate in the good times and avoid the bad times. Are the calls always correct? Are the trades always positive? Definitely not, but we know that there is only one thing worse than being wrong, and that is staying wrong.

We don't think there is any way to get over whipsaw trades. We hate them, our clients hate them, and people quit using investing strategies because of them. Yet, they are never going away, they are absolutely part of the process and cannot be avoided. We think it just takes experience to get used to whipsaws, if one ever does. Taking a longer-term view of a strategy's investment results and not focusing on the current trade that may not be working is one way to make whipsaws more tolerable.

There are, however, ways to reduce the number of whipsaw trades that occur in any rules-based strategy, and that is to de-sensitize the model to the market's actions; one such example would be using wider stops. We caution against this approach to whipsaws as it may reduce the frequency of them, but can also reduce overall performance, especially during bear markets. Having wider stops means you'll stay invested during more uptrends, as smaller pullbacks do not trigger selling, but you'll inevitably not get out of the way as quickly during corrections and bear markets, forcing you to ride the market down further before selling. Know that whatever stop level you choose, there will be times when the market does not cooperate. Adjusting a model based upon sound principles so that the whipsaws in the recent past are reduced or eliminated likely leads to whipsaws at other times and worse returns where it matters most – in the future.

Ironically, most buy & hold investors are really just very de-sensitized tactical investors, because they do eventually sell near market lows when the pain of further losses is far more than they can tolerate! Very few have the ability to always implement the "hold" portion of buy & hold, and we don't think it is a good plan for most investors with serious money at stake. We think it is better to accept the whipsaws and avoid the devastation of bear markets.

Dance with the Trend,

Greg Morris

Grant Morris


Grant Morris
About the author: , CFA, CFP® specializes in tactical investment strategies and technical analysis for McElhenny Sheffield Capital Management (MSCM). Grant joined MSCM after developing a rules-based trend following strategy to manage his personal investable assets. Through extensive research and analysis, Grant has found that his disciplined trend following approach allows him to participate in most of the “good times” in the stock market while avoiding much of the downside; resulting in larger compounded returns over full market cycles, as compared to typical buy-and-hold strategies. Grant now manages multiple tactical ETF strategies for MSCM clients as well as for his own accounts. Learn More
Greg Morris
About the author: has been a technical market analyst for over 45 years ranging from analysis software development, to website analysis and education, to money management. He has written four books: Candlestick Charting Explained (and its companion workbook), The Complete Guide to Market Breadth Indicators, and Investing with the Trend. A graduate of the Navy Fighter Weapons "Top Gun" School, Greg is a former Navy fighter pilot who flew F-4 Phantoms on the USS Independence.  He also holds a degree in Aerospace Engineering from the University of Texas. Greg has a long history of understanding market dynamics and portfolio management. Learn More
Subscribe to Dancing with the Trend to be notified whenever a new post is added to this blog!
comments powered by Disqus